Mihhail Kõlvart, the head of the opposition Center Party in Estonia, has taken a bold step by sending a letter to Chancellor of Justice Ülle Madise, urging her to seek the repeal of the Motor Vehicle Tax Act. Kõlvart argues that the act is in violation of the Estonian Constitution and poses a threat to society’s welfare.
In his letter, Kõlvart emphasizes the importance of upholding the principles of the constitution, particularly the welfare state provision outlined in Article 10. He believes that the introduction of the car tax, at a time when taxpayers are already burdened and inflation is on the rise, could increase the risk of poverty in society. Kõlvart’s concern for the vulnerable members of society is evident in his call for a thorough analysis and consideration of the broader implications of tax increases.
One of the key issues raised by Kõlvart is the unequal treatment of people with disabilities in the amended car tax law. Despite the president’s refusal to promulgate the initial draft due to concerns about unequal treatment, the coalition decided to remove all tax exemptions and replace them with minimal subsidies. This move not only fails to cover the costs of the car tax for people with disabilities but also jeopardizes their access to other essential support services.
Furthermore, Kõlvart highlights the lack of tax exemptions for large families and residents of rural areas who rely on their vehicles for daily use. He points out that while the government is considering cuts to child benefits and reducing investments in infrastructure, the burden of the car tax falls disproportionately on those who can least afford it.
In addition to the substantive issues with the car tax law, Kõlvart criticizes the unconstitutional nature of the legislative process in the Riigikogu. He argues that by bundling together amendments and limiting the rights of the parliamentary minority, the coalition is undermining democracy and preventing meaningful participation in shaping tax policies.
Despite Kõlvart’s efforts to challenge the car tax law, the president ultimately promulgated the amended legislation, which is set to take effect on January 1. This decision underscores the challenges faced by opposition parties in influencing policy outcomes and protecting the interests of marginalized groups.
In conclusion, Mihhail Kõlvart’s letter to the Chancellor of Justice highlights the importance of upholding constitutional principles, protecting vulnerable members of society, and promoting democratic participation in the legislative process. His advocacy for a fair and equitable tax system reflects a commitment to social justice and the well-being of all Estonian citizens.
